Please Wait a Moment

Explore Hayward's Best Eats: A Guide to Local Restaurant  Favorites

Welcome to Hayward! Whether you're here for adventure or relaxation, you've got to check out our local dining scene. Here's the scoop on some of our favorite local resturants:

Robin's Nest: This is the go-to place for a big, hearty breakfast. Their pancakes are huge and super fluffy, perfect for satisfying your morning hunger. Also, don’t miss the Irish Benedict - it’s a game-changer. The café's vibe is friendly and cozy, making you feel right at home.

Anglers Bar and Grill: Looking for a chill place to grab a bite in the evening? Anglers is where it's at. The fish taxidermy mounts add a cool, local touch. The menu has all the good stuff - burgers, fries, salads, and more. Plus, the laid-back atmosphere is perfect for hanging out with friends.

Hayward Family Restaurant: This diner is a local staple for both breakfast and lunch. Expect generous portions of all your favorites like pancakes, omelets, and sandwiches. It’s a comfortable spot where everyone feels welcome, and the friendly staff makes sure of it.

Angry Minnow Brew Pub: Set in a neat, historic building, this pub has a fantastic vibe. They brew their own beer and it’s definitely worth a try. The food is great too, with some creative twists on pub classics. It’s a fun place for a night out, especially when they have live music.

Tally Ho Supper Club: For a classic Wisconsin supper club experience, Tally Ho is the place. Their prime rib on a Saturday night is a must-have, and pair it with an Old Fashioned for the full experience. The place has an old-school charm and the staff are super friendly.

Rusty Hook: If you’re craving some BBQ, you can’t go wrong with Rusty Hook. Their barbecue is seriously amazing - think smoky, tender, and full of flavor. It’s the kind of place that'll have you planning your next visit before you even leave.

Props Landing: Sitting right on Round Lake, Props Landing offers a fantastic waterfront dining experience. Enjoy your meal with a view of the lake, making it the perfect spot for a relaxing lunch or dinner. Their setting is as good as their food, and that’s saying something!

Coops Pizza: No trip to Hayward is complete without a stop at Coops Pizza. It’s not just about the pizza here (which is delicious, by the way), but also the huge fish tank with bluegill, bass, and northern. It's fun for the whole family and a real talking point.

The Moccasin: Looking for a cool place to grab a drink after dinner? Head over to The Moccasin. It's a classic dive bar with an incredible display of fish taxidermy, including a world-record musky. It’s the perfect spot to wind down your day with some local color and good company.

Each of these establishments brings something unique to the table, from traditional American diners to cozy pubs and elegant supper clubs. Whether you're looking for a hearty breakfast, a casual drink, or a sophisticated dinner, Hayward's dining scene has much to offer.